This is not your father's Browser War
Mozilla is upset that Microsoft won't allow alternative browsers on Windows on ARM. (What's Windows on ARM? It's the tablet/phone/embedded version of Windows 8.) On Hacker News conversation immediately turns to comparisons with Apple's refusal to allow non-webkit browsers on iOS and its refusal to allow users to configure third-party browsers as the default browser. And then of course comes the "Apple is even eviler than Microsoft" and "Microsoft : IE :: Apple : Safari" arguments.
Irony
Why do we have all these browsers today? I would argue that the proliferation of alternative browsers can be traced to Microsoft's arrogance after 1997. In essence, Microsoft drove Netscape into the ground by creating a better, leaner browser (IE4).. It then sealed the deal by releasing IE5.1 for Mac, which destroyed Netscape's remaining user base. But, IE5.1 languished unloved and Mac users got desperate. Intrepid Mac hackers grabbed Gecko (Mozilla's rendering engine) and wrapped a lean, native UI around it (now known as Camino). This quickly gained popularity on the Mac, and users of Mozilla on other platforms quickly got jealous of Mac users having a lean, relatively non-buggy and non-bloated alternative to IE, so Firefox was born as a cross-platform Camino. Eventually, Apple itself got sick of being beholden to a crippled, unloved version of IE, and decided to build its own browser, which it based on KHTML. This became webkit, and it now powers almost all of Apple's more credible rivals as well as Safari.So you can trace almost all of this back to Microsoft's failure to follow through on IE for Mac. Having won the desktop war, they got complacent.
Closed : Bad :: Open : Stupid
The argument among the "Apple is closed and evil" crowd runs something like this. Once upon a time phones were an open fairyland. Then along came Apple and created a walled garden. Luckily, Google came along and produced a new, even better, open garden. Yay.In fact, once upon a time phones were a closed cesspit. Apple came along and created a walled garden with a well-marked entrance and a bouncer. Then Google came along and decided that building walls and hiring bouncers violated its "no customer service" policy.